12/03/2011
Maine’s Canadian Border
Last night I found myself wondering whether in colonial America, the future provinces of Canada were just more British colonies. Was there any real difference between Nova Scotia (then including New Brunswick) and Massachusetts (then including Maine)? In 1700 did one side think of itself as part of a different nation or did the concept of Canada and the United States appear only after the Revolutionary War?
Ignoring for the time being the huge part played by France, by the 1770s all of the colonies were known as part of the British Empire until the War of Independence. Thereafter the northern colonies were called British North America. Ontario and Quebec became the Provence of Canada in 1841 and the rest joined as the Dominion of Canada in 1867. So the answer is yes, the concept of Canada as a nation was a result of the independence of the 13 colonies to the south.
The northern colonies were where those loyal to the Crown fled during the revolution. I was surprised to learn that among my ancestors were loyalists. My 6th great grandfather John James Glassford (1708 – 1792), a farmer in the Albany, NY area, because of his allegiances was chased out, had his home burned and lost 300 acres. He and his wife and family had to settle on the British side of Niagara and to petition the British government for restoration of his losses. Many present day Canadians can trace their ancestral roots to New York and New England.

Maine border claims, blue is the current border. From http://www.upperstjohn.com/history/northeastborder.htm
In the early days of our state we even had an almost-war with Canada over our northern boundary. The Aroostook War started in 1838 because the Treaty of Paris, which ended hostilities after the War of Independence, was vague about the border. No shots were fired but both sides spent huge amounts on war preparations. Fort Knox near Bucksport on the way to Acadia from Boston is evidence. The Aroostook War deserves a post of its own, so in this context let’s just say it began a tradition of compromise and cooperation between Maine and her Canadian neighbors, Quebec and New Brunswick.
Maine’s border with Canada stretches 611 miles, third to Alaska’s 1538 miles and Michigan’s 1160 (but most of that is through the Great Lakes). There are some odd border areas. For example, in order for Canadians to get to Campobello Island, they have to take a ferry from Deer Island, New Brunswick or more easily, drive across the border to Lubec, ME and cross on the short bridge. Two border crossings. Campobello Island is fittingly home to Roosevelt Campobello International Park, jointly administered by the Canadian and American park services.
The Aroostook Valley Country Club has nine holes on each side of the international border. During Prohibition, American golfers could amble over to the Canadian clubhouse and have a few drinks before heading back. Until the heightened security following 9/11 this was no big deal. Then the border patrol got into the act, informing golfers they were breaking the law if they crossed to the second nine holes without going through the nearest border crossing. See U.S. swings at terrorists, hits golfers – Chicago Tribune. Things got even sillier when it was revealed that farmer Nick Pedersen couldn’t get to his New Brunswick farm without using a local US road, which he had been doing for 80 years, without Customs involvement. The complicated convolutions of his situation can be seen here.
In Estcourt Station, Maine, (above) just at the very top of Maine and opposite Quebec, is an odd little outpost accessible only by Canadian roads. Besides a few farmed fields the only thing going on on the American side is a gas station, where Canadians can save a few dimes on a gallon of gas. The new security regime warns Canadians to check in at the border crossing before buying gas, which most ignore. Michel Jalbert ignored it and it cost him 5 months in jail and $5,000 in bills, fees and lost income while being held in a US jail. Admittedly, he had a shotgun and a criminal record, but it seemed to most a hefty price for saving a few bucks in gas.
Lost in all of this is the genuine affection between our two nations and the warm feelings between neighbors and relatives across the line. Atlantic Canada especially seems to identify itself with the States, it seemed like everyone I met in Nova Scotia, as well as local hero Alexander Graham Bell, spent considerable time in the US. Now it is necessary to have a passport or passport card to get across, although I got onto Campobello in 2009 without one. Somehow the border crossings make us seem like enemies, but I’m hopeful this is a passing phase.
Filed under Acadia, History by on Dec 3rd, 2011. 2 Comments.






















